Target Report: What in the World is Schutzschirmverfahren?

Schutzschirmverfahren (shu̇ts-ˌshir-m fər-ˈfä-rən): a German word literally translated as “Protective Shield Proceedings,” but in practical terms, it is the German equivalent of a self-administered, court-supervised proceeding under Chapter 11 of the US Bankruptcy Code.

Exit, Consolidate, or Invest

Despite the recent spate of numerous plant closures and total plant auctions, we do not see evidence of widespread company failures in the printing industry. Rather, recent transactional activity suggests something more structural at work. The industry is not collapsing; it continues to be sorted out by market forces as the demand for printed products changes.

Three distinct pathways are emerging: excess capacity is being wrung out of the system via company and plant closures, often outside formal restructuring processes; core mature print markets are continuously consolidating through many, sometimes small, local transactions; and capital continues to flow toward the growth segments, in particular packaging and digital print technologies, albeit at a much slower pace than in previous years. Together, these dynamics are reshaping the printing and packaging industry from the inside out.

Wrung Out - Manroland Sheetfed Files Bankruptcy

One of the most highly respected manufacturers of printing equipment, Manroland Sheetfed, entered into bankruptcy proceedings in Germany under that country’s Insolvency Code, which provides the option for management to retain control of the company while restructuring, rather than being replaced by a court-appointed administrator.

The Manroland press line traces its origin back to 1844 in Augsburg, Germany, and has been associated with many innovations throughout its long history. The company initially focused on producing steam engines, but within a couple of decades had expanded into manufacturing printing presses. In 1875, the company introduced the Albatross Press, which produced up to 700 sheets per hour, a very productive rate for a sheetfed press (“Albatross” clearly had a different, more positive connotation at the time). The company came into its own in 1911 with the introduction of its first sheetfed offset press. Another milestone was achieved in 1951 when the company introduced the 4-color sheetfed Ultra press at Drupa, revolutionary at the time for its “planetary cylinder” design, which enabled full-color printing in one pass through the press.

The company progressed over the following decades with a convoluted series of mergers. The 1979 merger with the MAN Group brought web press production into the company. To gain entry into the US market, the company marketed its presses under the brand name Miele-Roland, piggybacking on the reputation of Miele presses.

Manroland, with both sheetfed and web press manufacturing under its belt, churned through several ownership structures: corporate enterprise, foreign, and private equity. Following its first insolvency filing in 2012, the company emerged from that restructuring as two separate entities, Manroland Sheetfed, embracing sheetfed technology, under the umbrella of UK-based Langley Holdings. The legacy web press business was purchased by Possehl Group, a German industrial conglomerate, eventually merging it with Goss International to form Manroland Goss. (See The Target Report: Press Onward! - March 2018).

We may be seeing the end of the sheetfed branch of the Manroland family of printing presses. The CEO of Langley Holdings was quoted in the company’s review as saying, “The situation at Manroland Sheetfed is unsustainable.” The company’s restructuring expert noted that they “will have to implement drastic and far-reaching measures” and that it “is regrettable that a great many jobs will be lost.” Over the past couple of decades, much of the packaging market has shifted to Koenig & Bauer (KBA) for its very-large-format offset presses. Komori has made significant inroads into the commercial market for high-speed automated offset presses. Heidelberg has held its ground in both the commercial and packaging markets. Given these market trends, we will not be surprised if Manroland Sheetfed exits the manufacture of printing presses and is consigned to simply servicing its legacy of installed machines.

Consolidation as the Default Path

The most visible activity in March was the steady cadence of small and mid-sized acquisitions across commercial printing. These were not transformative platform deals or private equity-backed roll-ups. Instead, they were overwhelmingly local, strategic tuck-ins, transactions driven by geography, customer overlap, and operational efficiency.

BP Print Group’s acquisition of PrintFast Marketing Solutions in New Jersey, Andrick & Associates’ tuck-in of Target Graphics in Florida, and PackEdge’s purchase of Keno Graphics in Connecticut, all follow a similar pattern: buyers and sellers operating in the same regional markets, combining to improve utilization and retain customer relationships. At the lower end of the market, consolidation via tuck-in transactions provides owners with a graceful exit path as the commercial printing industry volume slowly declines.

Franchise and network operators continue to play an important role in this consolidation dynamic. The Minuteman Press in Kalamazoo, Michigan, acquired local company JB Printing. In Iowa, the North Liberty franchise purchased Goodfellow Printing. The Allegra Marketing Print Mail franchise in Baltimore expanded its footprint by acquiring the Image360 franchise location in downtown Baltimore. These transactions demonstrate how franchise organizations now act as aggregation vehicles for many smaller, independent printers. The franchisors’ model: local ownership combined with broader branding and operational support, positions the franchise systems to absorb sub-scale competitors and attract entrepreneurial entrants into the printing industry.

Notably absent from the month’s activity were large-scale commercial print platform acquisitions. There were no multi-state roll-ups and no significant private equity entries into traditional print. The lack of headline transactions suggests that growth expectations are not driving consolidation, but rather that consolidation is occurring by necessity. For many operators, acquisition is less about expansion and more about survival: adding volume, improving equipment utilization, and maintaining relevance in increasingly competitive local markets while at the same time removing a competitor from the playing field. In the current market, consolidation is happening at the edges, not on a large scale, at least not yet.

Investment Flows Toward Packaging and Technology

In contrast to the fragmented and largely local nature of commercial print M&A, capital deployment in packaging and enabling technologies continues to occur at scale and with strategic intent. Altamont Capital Partners’ investment in Key Container Corporation reflects ongoing private equity interest in corrugated packaging, despite reports that demand for corrugated boxes has declined following a systemic reset after the post-Covid period, as well as online retailers shifting to paper bags and envelopes as more cost-effective carriers.

Similarly, CCL Industries’ $113 million (USD) acquisition of Sleever International underscores the strategic, long-term value of packaging companies, in this case, shrink-sleeve production. Consistent with the deal discipline that CCL has shown in the past, the multiple paid was 6.4x adjusted EBITDA. (See The Target Report: CCL Industries Breaks the Rules – January 2022). This multiple is not only a sign of CCL’s approach but moreover is indicative of the cooling off of the red-hot market for packaging companies, even allowing that shrink sleeves were not as hot as labels and flexible packaging. Even more striking among the deal metrics revealed was that net tangible assets are expected to represent 90% of the purchase price, leaving just 10% to be allocated to goodwill.

 An Industry Being Sorted

Taken together, the March data does not portray an industry in crisis, nor is it indicative of a booming business for print and packaging companies. It describes an industry being sorted. Three pathways are becoming increasingly distinct. As is the case with many of the closures noted in our deal log, and as may be the case with Manroland Sheetfed, when the headwinds are too strong, some fold up their tent and close up shop. Consolidation is reshaping core print markets as local operators combine to remain viable, with the survivors absorbing work from exiting companies. And finally, investment is still flowing into packaging, labels, and digital print technologies, the industry segments aligned with growth, and attracting capital.

Click to enlarge.

Click to enlarge.

Click to enlarge.

View The Target Report online, complete with deal logs and source links for March 2026

For more information on Graphic Arts Advisors, visit graphicartsadvisors.com